If a chimney stack on your Sawston home is no longer in use, you have a genuine choice to make about materials and methods, and it pays to understand what each option actually involves.
Call any time. Calls are answered day and night and passed straight to our roofers.
When a chimney is causing problems - or when you simply want shot of the maintenance it demands - there are three routes: targeted repair, capping and leaving the stack in place, or a full take-down with the roof made good. The right answer depends on the condition of the stack, how it looks from the street and what you want from the finished result.
Capping the pot and leaving the stack standing only makes sense if the brickwork and flashing are still sound. If pointing is failing or flashing has lifted, leaving the stack means the problems continue. For most redundant chimneys that have been neglected for several years, removal is the more practical long-term answer.
A take-down means reducing the stack to below roof level, typically to just below the flashing line. The opening left in the roof is then framed out with timber, boarded or sarked, and covered with tiles or slates to match the rest of the roof. The edges where the new section meets the old roof are weatherproofed with flashing or membrane detailing. The inside of the chimney breast in the loft space is usually capped with a board or slab so the former flue space is sealed.
The quality of the finished job depends heavily on the materials chosen at each stage. Below is an honest look at the main decisions and what they mean for you.
Roofing the gap where the chimney stood means finding tiles that match your existing roof well enough not to look patched. This is straightforward on a modern concrete interlocking tile roof - most manufacturers still produce the same profiles they were using twenty or thirty years ago, and a good roofing merchant can often supply a match from current stock.
On older properties with plain clay tiles, handmade clay tiles or natural slate, matching is harder. Clay tiles vary by batch and age, and weathering changes their colour over time. Second-hand tiles from a salvage yard are often the best answer for a close visual match, though you pay more for the sourcing time and the tiles themselves cost more per unit. Natural Welsh slate in particular can be very difficult to match on an older roof - the specific quarry and grade affect both colour and texture.
Concrete tiles are the easiest and cheapest to match. Clay tiles from salvage are harder but give a better aesthetic result on period properties. Slate matching is the most involved and should always use like-for-like material rather than a synthetic substitute.
Where the new tiles meet the existing roof, the junction needs to be properly waterproofed. On most domestic roofs, this is done with code 4 lead flashing, which is the standard weight for soakers, step flashings and aprons on pitched roofs in the UK. Code 4 lead is 1.8 mm thick and is appropriate for most residential chimney and abutment flashing work.
Lead is the traditional material and, when dressed and fixed correctly, outlasts nearly every other option. It is also the most expensive material for this purpose - lead is priced by weight and the price fluctuates, but budget for lead flashing as a meaningful part of any chimney job. The alternative used on some jobs is a self-adhesive lead-effect flashing tape, which is cheaper and faster to fit but does not last as long and is more prone to failure at corners and overlaps. For a permanent result, formed lead is the right choice.
Once the stack is down, the opening in the roof needs to be framed in. This means fitting noggins or cripple rafters between the existing rafters to support the new tile battens. The boarding underneath - whether that is OSB, plywood or sarking board - needs to be a decent thickness to give the battens something solid to fix into. Cutting corners on the timber frame is the main reason patched areas on roofs end up sagging or moving over time.
Below the boarding, an underlay is fitted. Standard polypropylene underlay is fine on most pitched roofs. On a lower-pitch section or where the junction with the existing roof is more complex, a breathable membrane with a higher water column rating gives more protection. The underlay should lap properly over the existing underlay rather than just butting up to it.
Some chimney stacks sit at or near the junction of a flat or very low-pitch roof section. Where the new infill area has a pitch below about 15 degrees, tiles are not appropriate and a flat roof material is needed. EPDM rubber membrane is the most practical modern choice here. It is a single-ply membrane bonded or mechanically fixed to the deck, with a lifespan often quoted at 20 years or more by manufacturers, and it handles standing water without deteriorating. It can be finished in a way that drains properly to the existing guttering.
Felt is the older alternative and still used, but a modern EPDM system is more durable at this application. If your chimney stack sits at a complicated pitch junction, it is worth discussing this specifically with your roofer before work starts.
The most common source of a chimney leak is the lead flashing pulling away from the stack or cracking at a corner. Water then runs down between the stack and the roof tiles and into the roof space. The second most common cause is failed pointing - mortar that has dropped out of the joints lets rain soak straight into the brickwork. Internal water then tracks down inside the chimney breast and appears as damp on a bedroom or landing wall.
A cracked or displaced chimney pot lets rain fall straight down the flue onto internal brickwork that is never designed to be wet. On a redundant chimney with no liner, there is nothing to stop that water travelling all the way to the fireplace opening.
A full chimney take-down with tiling over, including scaffold, typically ranges from £1,200 to £2,500 for a single stack on a standard two-storey house. The main variables are scaffold cost, tile matching difficulty and the complexity of the junction detailing. A straightforward job on a modern concrete tile roof at the lower end, a slate or clay tile job needing salvage materials at the upper end.
Repointing alone on a stack in otherwise sound condition costs roughly £400 to £800. Replacing lead flashing costs roughly £150 to £400 depending on the quantity. These figures are honest typical UK ranges and your own quote will depend on the specifics of your property.
We cover Sawston from our base in Haverhill. If you are weighing up whether to repair or remove a chimney stack, call us and we will give you a straight view of the options based on what is actually happening on your roof - not a standard script. We can advise on tile matching, flashing materials and the best approach for your roof pitch and tile type.
No obligation · We'll call you to arrange a free visit
Call any time. Calls are answered day and night and passed straight to our roofers.
